Is it NOT a Magic: The Gathering card?

The Queen of Spades (someone else told me to...)

God I hope the answer is no to that question

Is it Unglued's Zombie Token?

I don't think tokens are cards. But any way, something like that would be extremely tricksy, as it doesn't have a printed P/T.

Innuendo, what kind of Zombie token? Since there are more than one kind of Zombie tokens.

I honestly don't know any of the different ones, the last printed zombie 1/1 token.

Fafnir was right, but he guessed when twenty questions had asked. I considered the answer as a Magic Card because it's printed with collector number 91 at Unglued, so I counted it as a Magic card. This is something controversial, so, am I the one who would be the "host" again?

No, let's let faf do it...the end was kinda muddy there and he did get it right

O_o It really was the unglued token? Oh well. No more tokens from now on though.

What card I'm thinking of?

If you look back, Fafnir was the only one to ask a -proper- question after the end, so I think he gets 2 points. Innuendo - sooo close, but you didn't actually ask a proper question until after Fafnir did his. I'm going to assume from the other responses that nobody is going to argue this reasoning (except maybe Alex, since he's fighting to get in the top 2 ).

Fafnir - 38
Picks-at-Flies - 37
ALEX Ryugami - 25
Ulxiz - 14
Aurora Illumina - 9
innuendo - 6
Idle Muse - 6
emperorkingx - 2

assuming it's 3/2, 2/3 still:

Is it White, Blue, or Black?
Scathe Zombies

Is it Uncommon/Rare?
Counterpsell

Is it a Permanent?

20. It is white, blue or black.
19. It is uncommon or rare.
18. It is a permanent.

WRONG WRONG WRONG WRONG, WRONG WRONG WRONG WRONG:
Scathe Zombies
Counterspell

Three for Three, I'm shooting a million!

(I'll let someone else take the next 2/3)

Is it a creature?

Is it monocoloured?

Serra Angel
Leviathan
Grozoth

Edit: finally got sensible guesses.

20. It is white, blue or black.
19. It is uncommon or rare.
18. It is a permanent.
17. It is a creature.
16. It's not monocoloured.

WRONG :
Scathe Zombies
Counterspell
Serra Angel
Leviathan
Grozoth

Is it extended-legal?
Deepfire Elemental

Converted mana cost <= 3?
Rhys the Redeemed

20. It is white, blue or black.
19. It is uncommon or rare.
18. It is a permanent.
17. It is a creature.
16. It's not monocoloured.
15. It's not extended-legal.
14. Its converted mana cost is 4 or greater.

Don't waste your time always searching for those wasted years:
Scathe Zombies
Counterspell
Serra Angel
Leviathan
Grozoth
Deepfire Elemental
Rhys the Redeemed

Power <= 3?
Tobias Andrion

(this list got very short, very quickly)

Is it red or green?
Atogatog

20. It is white, blue or black.
19. It is uncommon or rare.
18. It is a permanent.
17. It is a creature.
16. It's not monocoloured.
15. It's not extended-legal.
14. Its converted mana cost is 4 or greater.
13. Its power is 4 or higher
12. It's not red or green.

Don't waste your time always searching for those wasted years:
Scathe Zombies
Counterspell
Serra Angel
Leviathan
Grozoth
Deepfire Elemental
Rhys the Redeemed
Tobias Andrion
Atogatog

Is it Human?
Chromium

Is it black?
Sivitri Scarzam

20. It is white, blue or black.
19. It is uncommon or rare.
18. It is a permanent.
17. It is a creature.
16. It's not monocoloured.
15. It's not extended-legal.
14. Its converted mana cost is 4 or greater.
13. Its power is 4 or higher
12. It's not red or green.
11. It is Human.
10. It's not black.

Don't waste your time always searching for those wasted years:
Scathe Zombies
Counterspell
Serra Angel
Leviathan
Grozoth
Deepfire Elemental
Rhys the Redeemed
Tobias Andrion
Atogatog
Chromium
Sivitri Scarzam

Does it have a keyword?
Kasimir the lone wolf

20. It is white, blue or black.
19. It is uncommon or rare.
18. It is a permanent.
17. It is a creature.
16. It's not monocoloured.
15. It's not extended-legal.
14. Its converted mana cost is 4 or greater.
13. Its power is 4 or higher
12. It's not red or green.
11. It is Human.
10. It's not black.
9. It has a keyword.

Don't waste your time always searching for those wasted years:
Scathe Zombies
Counterspell
Serra Angel
Leviathan
Grozoth
Deepfire Elemental
Rhys the Redeemed
Tobias Andrion
Atogatog
Chromium
Sivitri Scarzam
Kasimir the Lone Wolf

Does it have First strike?
Hunding Gjornerson

(pretty sure there is only one option if this isn't it)

20. It is white, blue or black.
19. It is uncommon or rare.
18. It is a permanent.
17. It is a creature.
16. It's not monocoloured.
15. It's not extended-legal.
14. Its converted mana cost is 4 or greater.
13. Its power is 4 or higher
12. It's not red or green.
11. It is Human.
10. It's not black.
9. It has a keyword.
8. It does have first strike.

One guess to rule them all:
Scathe Zombies
Counterspell
Serra Angel
Leviathan
Grozoth
Deepfire Elemental
Rhys the Redeemed
Tobias Andrion
Atogatog
Chromium
Sivitri Scarzam
Kasimir the Lone Wolf
Hunding Gjornersen

Is it's text: "First Strike. ; Creatures with islandwalk can be blocked as though they did not have islandwalk."
Gosta Dirk!

Yes, it's Gosta Dirk, teaching designers everywhere how to beat "can't" rules with "as though".

Victory goes to Innuendo with 7 points.

Shazaam?

I'm gone this weekend, so go ahead and log up some questions and i'll answer when I get back.

What card am I thinking of?

(3/2, 2/3 for first two posters)

Is it red, green, or white?
Ironroot Treefolk

Is it a creature, enchantment, or artifact?
Scryb Sprites

Is it in an extended-legal set?

Is it monocoloured?
Ghostfire

Is it a non-creature permanent?
Ghostway

Dauthi Slayer

Thanks picks, i completely forgot about this! I'll edit back in the answers so don't post!

::QUESTIONS::
1.) It is Red, Green, or White
2.) It is not A creature, enchantment, or artifact
3.) It is in an extended legal set
4.) It is not monocolored
5.) It is not a non-creature permanent

::BAD GUESSES::
1.) Ironroot Treefolk
2.) Scryb Sprites
3.) Ghostfire
4.) Ghostaway
5.) Dauthi Slayer

Is it dual-coloured?
Brilliant Ultimatum

Is it blue or black?
Biomantic Mastery

-bump-

Hmm, my tracker was blocknig this thread, I just happened to see it in the forum layout...

That's really odd, I'll just add it threads i'm watching. Sorry guys

::QUESTIONS::
20.) It is Red, Green, or White
19.) It is not A creature, enchantment, or artifact
18.) It is in an extended legal set
17.) It is not monocolored
16.) It is not a non-creature permanent
15.) It is Dual-Colored
14.) It is not Blue or Black

::BAD GUESSES::
Ironroot Treefolk
Scryb Sprites
Ghostfire
Ghostaway
Dauthi Slayer
Brilliant Ultimatum
Biomantic Mastery

Is it Hybrid?
Rally the Righteous

Is it standard-legal?
Seeds of Strength

::QUESTIONS::
20.) It is Red, Green, or White
19.) It is not A creature, enchantment, or artifact
18.) It is in an extended legal set
17.) It is not monocolored
16.) It is not a non-creature permanent
15.) It is Dual-Colored
14.) It is not Blue or Black
13.) It is not Hybrid
12.) It is not standard legal.

::BAD GUESSES::
Ironroot Treefolk
Scryb Sprites
Ghostfire
Ghostaway
Dauthi Slayer
Brilliant Ultimatum
Biomantic Mastery
Rally the Righteous
Seeds of Strength

Is it an instant?
Brightflame

Does it have a CMC of 2?
Razias Purification

::QUESTIONS::
20.) It is Red, Green, or White
19.) It is not A creature, enchantment, or artifact
18.) It is in an extended legal set
17.) It is not monocolored
16.) It is not a non-creature permanent
15.) It is Dual-Colored
14.) It is not Blue or Black
13.) It is not Hybrid
12.) It is not standard legal.
11.) It is an instant.
10.) It's CMC is 2.

::BAD GUESSES::
Ironroot Treefolk
Scryb Sprites
Ghostfire
Ghostaway
Dauthi Slayer
Brilliant Ultimatum
Biomantic Mastery
Rally the Righteous
Seeds of Strength
Brightflame
Razias Purification

Lightning Helix?

Yay, you win.

I figured it would be an easy on.

And my score doubles.

Fafnir - 38
Picks-at-Flies - 37
ALEX Ryugami - 25
Aurora Illumina - 18
Ulxiz - 14
innuendo - 6
Idle Muse - 6
emperorkingx - 2

What card am I thinking of?

Is it White, Blue, or Black?
Ghost Quarter

Is it a permanent?
Giant Growth

Is it Uncommon or Rare?

19. Yes, it's white, blue, or black.
18. No, it's not a permanent.
17. Yes, it's uncommon or rare.

Cards made of 100% pure, genuine, FAIL:
Ghost Quarter
Giant Growth

Is it multicoloured?
Is it uncommon?

Aesthetic Consultation
Agonizing Memories
Altars Light